, ,

Broadway, Who? Generic Theater Makes a New Home on Granby Street, Debuting with “Putting It Together”

Photo courtesy of Charles Townsend

As we walked into the Masonic Temple on Granby Street for the first time, it felt like a new era had begun for Generic Theater, and we weren’t quite sure what to expect from it all – and then we noticed there, the same crew of ticket takers, and there, Julianne Baker, still greeting people and making everyone in the audience feel seen and comfortable, bringing a modicum of continuity to the new space after many years of Generic lurking in the depths of Chrysler Hall.  And then, on stage, we saw champagne flutes and bottles – and we realized that “Putting It Together”, the aptly named Sondheim musical revue which Generic is putting on as its first title in their new home, is meant to be a simple and fun show to serve as the backdrop to a four weekend celebration that Generic has survived and has a path forward into the future.

The show begins with what is basically a comedy routine about the proper manners required of an audience from the talented Alexander McDaniel, who keeps us smiling all night as he lightly narrates the themes of the evening, while also participating in some of the musical numbers (most memorably in the second act, mimicking his love interest in hilarious fashion in the song “Buddy’s Blues”).  The second number, the eponymous “Putting It Together” is a funny group song about all the little annoyances of being an actor, and from there, the show tips into Sondheim’s catalogue, with a focus on two couples.

The first, more mature couple concentrates on songs that explore what the second half of marriage looks like, trying to find ways past the boredom and loneliness that many years of marriage can bring (or so I’m told).  Jeff Joyner, as the “Man 1” character, is a bit operatic, and brings an air of high class to his parts, like the rich guy you are seated with at a benefit dinner that he paid $2,000/seat to attend (and you got a comped ticket to).  But – under the surface – he doesn’t have it as figured out as he appears to.  Meanwhile, Sarah Kingsley is “Woman 1”, lending her powerful vocals to the role where she often is sort of bitter, but tempered by a cleverness to her words such that the audience tends to root for her, as each of us have experienced those feelings at one point or another.

The second, younger couple gets songs exploring the passion and confusion of the early parts of relationships.  Alicia Searles, as “Woman 2”, shows off her beautiful and playful head voice in the early-in-the-night showstopper “Lovely”, and continues to impress throughout, navigating, with Kingsley, Sondheim’s surprisingly long list of numbers that pit one woman against the other, all leading up to the duet most devilish and yet most entertaining, “There’s Always a Woman”.  The other side of the couple, “Man 2”, is played by Caden Barley.  Barley brings sort of a goofy fun to the role as he seemingly society climbs, giving a sense of “I’m just happy to be here”, no matter where the “here” may be.  Barley has an exceptionally clear voice, with an explosive quality to his upper register – and he even breaks out tap shoes for a number – always a surprise, and always delightful.

This show isn’t really about plot (you are warned of this in the opening minutes of the show), but rather, leans into Sondheim’s catalogue of dialogue-driven songs, where Sondheim lets the rhythm of the conversation lead, and he finds a chord progression or two that he likes for that song and then plays with variations of that throughout, giving each a persistent “stuck in your head” quality.  The live band (who does an excellent job), as well as the tech crew (strong spotlight work, with string lighting under gauzy curtains giving a bit of glamour and mood to the evening, and impressively no sound issues in the new space) must leave every night humming one tune or another. 

We can’t overstate how amazing it is that the team at Generic has been able to complete a move to a completely new theater (which, by the way, was not a theater at all just a few short months ago) and not miss a beat in getting their 46th season started.  So cheers to Sondheim, but even more so, cheers to everyone at this priceless hidden gem of a theater.  We can’t wait to be audience members for years to come.

(New this season, our wonderful cat Pepper wanted her voice heard as well, if you all will oblige her…)

Pepper’s Purr-fect Picks: No cats on stage, but there is a one named Peppy (which, of course, is very similar to my name) in the program.  And a big congrats on the big move!  Two paws up!

(Pepper also canonically sells concessions at the various community theaters.  She always comes up with a themed drink special, which is for entertainment purposes only and notably IS NOT in fact available for purchase)

Pepper’s Drink Special: “Stephen Sondheim Sherbet Party Punch” – my mom’s secret family-friendly party punch recipe, with rainbow sherbet on top.

Comments (

0

)